Excerpt from Written Testimony Submitted by U.S. Chemical Safety Board
Chairman Rafael Moure-Eraso to the Joint Committee: Senate Committee on
Environment and Public Works and the Senate Committee on Health,
Education, Labor, and Pensions hearing entitled, "Oversight of the
Implementation of the President’s Executive Order on Improving Chemical
Facility Safety and Security”:
"The most recent example is the tragic chemical accident at the major
DuPont chemical plant in La Porte, Texas, just east of Houston. On
November 15, 2014, there was a release of methyl mercaptan, a highly
toxic and volatile liquid, which DuPont itself has estimated at 23,000
pounds – a very significant quantity. Odors of the chemical were
reportedly discernible many miles from the plant. Four workers –
including operators and would-be rescuers – perished inside the
methomyl-production building where the release originated.
DuPont is certainly no “outlier.” In fact, DuPont has long been
regarded as one of industry’s leading lights in safety, and it markets
its safety programs to other companies. What happened last month,
however, was the fifth release incident at a DuPont facility that the
CSB has investigated since 2010, and three of these had associated
fatalities. While the CSB investigation remains underway in La Porte,
some preliminary facts are already emerging.
The incident occurred following an unplanned shutdown of the methomyl
unit due to inadvertent water dilution of a chemical storage tank
several days earlier. Efforts were underway to restart the process, but
problems occurred including plugged supply piping leading from the
methyl mercaptan storage tank. As efforts were underway to troubleshoot
these problems, it is likely that methyl mercaptan (and possibly other
toxic chemicals) inadvertently entered the interconnected process vent
system inside the building. The release occurred through a valve that
was opened as part of a routine effort to drain liquid from the vent
system in order to relieve pressure inside. We found that this vent
system had a history of periodic issues with unwanted liquid build-up,
and the valve in question was typically drained directly into the work
area inside the building, rather than into a closed system. In
addition, our investigators have found that the building’s ventilation
fans were not in service, and that the company did not effectively
implement good safety practices requiring personnel to wear appropriate
personal protective equipment (PPE) that was present at the facility.
Appropriate PPE would include equipment, such as supplied air
respirators, for workers performing potentially hazardous tasks inside
the building.
In summary, this was a complex process-related accident with tragic
results. It gives rise to a number of design and organizational safety
concerns. Its occurrence – taken along with other major accidents
afflicting large and small corporations – underscores the need for some
systemic reforms. It would be a serious and tragic mistake to consider
each of these accidents as just another isolated event, reflecting only
the limited practices of a small group of people operating outside
regulatory scrutiny. If it can happen at DuPont, I would submit it can
happen anywhere."
Read the complete CSB written testimony to joint committee from which above excerpt was taken
in this link
Contribute to the surviving victims of Bhopal by buying my book "Practical Process Safety Management"